Contextuality in Practical Reason by A. W. Price

, , Comments Off on Contextuality in Practical Reason by A. W. Price

By A. W. Price

A. W. fee explores the various ways that context is correct to our reasoning approximately what to do. He investigates the position of context in our interpretation and evaluate of useful inferences (especially from one goal to another), functional decisions (especially regarding the time period "ought"), inferences from conditional "ought"-judgements, and the ascription to brokers of purposes for motion. sensible inferences are topic to not a distinct common sense, yet to a teleology that they percentage with motion itself. Their inherent function is to ahead an finish of motion, and never to be logically legitimate. sensible judgments are often to be understood really to an implicit context of ambitions and situations. it seems that conflicting or imprudent "oughts" can appear as real after they are interpreted contextually, with a watch to diverse ends, and varied facets of a scenario. This makes applicable sure styles of inference that might another way license counter-intuitive conclusions. What purposes for motion are ascribable to an agent relies either at the context of motion, and at the deliberative context. evidence inform in want of activities opposed to a historical past of specific situations, and in methods whose relevance to an ascription to an agent of a cause of motion is dependent upon the viewpoint in which the ascription is made.

Show description

Read Online or Download Contextuality in Practical Reason PDF

Similar logic & language books

Philosophical Theories of Probability

This booklet offers a finished and systematic account of a number of the philosophical theories of likelihood and explains how they're similar. It covers the classical, logical, subjective, frequency, and propensity perspectives. Donald Gillies even offers a brand new idea of chance -the intersubjective-a improvement of the subjective conception.

The Logical Structure of the World and Pseudoproblems in Philosophy (Open Court Classics)

On hand for the 1st time in twenty years, listed here are very important works from the Twenties through the best-known consultant of the Vienna Circle. within the Logical constitution of the area, Carnap adopts the placement of “methodological solipsism” and exhibits that it truly is attainable to explain the realm from the instant facts of expertise.

Wittgenstein's Philosophical Investigations (S U N Y Series in Philosophy)

An innovative and interesting exposition of issues from Wittgenstein's Philosophical Investigations, this e-book is helping readers locate their approach round the "forest of feedback" that make up this vintage. Chapters on language, brain, colour, quantity, God, worth, and philosophy improve an important topic: that there are many sorts of language use--a sort philosophy must examine yet has a tendency to miss.

The Boundary Stones of Thought: An Essay in the Philosophy of Logic

The Boundary Stones of inspiration seeks to guard classical good judgment from a couple of assaults of a commonly anti-realist personality. Ian Rumfitt is sympathetic to a few of the premisses underlying those assaults. certainly, he regards a few of them as potent demanding situations to yes rules of classical semantics, particularly the primary of Bivalence.

Extra resources for Contextuality in Practical Reason

Sample text

But take this instance of (B): (C) I am going to get drunk. Whoever gets drunk is bound to have a hangover. So, I am going to have a hangover. And then consider the equivalent ‘mixed’ inference, with both first premise and conclusion replaced by expressions of intention: (D) I will get drunk. Whoever gets drunk is bound to have a hangover. So, I will have a hangover. This is wholly unintuitive as a practical inference: in a practical inference from an end, the conclusion relates to means, not to consequences.

Thus, if I wish to ϕ but know that it is impossible (which is perfectly consistent in the case of a wish), it would be absurd to feel logically compelled to wish to ψ, when I shall fail to ϕ even if I ψ. ’ So long as I retain that intention, I must intend that any necessary means form part of some set of means which together are sufficient. Thus I may now form an intention to ψ for the sake of ϕ’ing, although ψ’ing is necessary but insufficient for ϕ’ing, so long as I do not suppose that I have ψ’ed already, and have in mind to intend and enact other conditions take on a contextual disvalue that blocked my reason to ϕ from being also a reason to ψ.

What formulation of a logical starting-point might suit the example with which I began? ’ But adopting that would at once give up on the idea that practical conclusions arise through logical inference. For one thing, explicit ascriptions of psychological states have too limited implications to fit the purpose. ’ Yet it does not follow, if p entails q, and A believes that p, that A believes that q; for A may be unaware that p entails q. It is true that, if that is very evident, he might not count as believing that p if he doesn’t even implicitly believe that q; yet we may be certain that no subject believes everything that is entailed by the contents of his beliefs.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.01 of 5 – based on 26 votes